杏吧论坛

Dr Denisa Kostovicova CBG.7.03

This course is available on the MSc in Culture and Conflict in a Global Europe, MSc in Culture and Conflict in a Global Europe (杏吧论坛 & Columbia), MSc in Culture and Conflict in a Global Europe (杏吧论坛 & Sciences Po), MSc in European and International Politics and Policy, MSc in European and International Politics and Policy (杏吧论坛 and Bocconi), MSc in European and International Politics and Policy (杏吧论坛 and Sciences Po), MSc in European and International Public Policy (杏吧论坛 and Bocconi), MSc in European and International Public Policy (杏吧论坛 and Sciences Po), MSc in Gender (Rights and Human Rights), MSc in Gender, Peace and Security, MSc in International Migration and Public Policy and MSc in International Migration and Public Policy (杏吧论坛 and Sciences Po). This course is available with permission as an outside option to students on other programmes where regulations permit.

This course has a limited number of places (it is controlled access). In previous years we have been able to provide places for all students that apply but that may not continue to be the case.

The pursuit of justice in the aftermath of mass atrocity and gross human rights violations has become a norm in a globalised post-Cold War world. It rests on the premise that states and societies ought to engage with the difficult past in order to transition from conflict to peace. But, the limitations of transitional justice practices, such as war crimes trials, truth commissions, reparations and others, are now evident. Instead of promoting peace and reconciliation, they have often had the opposite impact: they have further divided communities, distorted the truth about suffering, and traumatised rather than dignified the victims. With a comparative focus on transitional justice practices in Europe and elsewhere, this course examines how the pursuit of post-conflict justice is theorised and tackles the puzzle of its unintended effects in societies transitioning from conflict and repressive rule.

The course starts with a review of transitional justice and reconciliation as fields of study and practice. Following the introductory part that relates the emergence of a global norm of transitional justice to the lessons from Europe’s history, the course proceeds with an examination of key mechanisms of transitional justice in various contexts: international trials, truth and reconciliation commissions, and lustrations. It then engages with more recent practices, such as the role of art and social media in transitional justice and reconciliation. Some of the examples we will examine include the work of the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia, domestic war crimes trials in Ukraine, de-Baathification process in Iraq, photography about the Rwandan genocide and digital memory activism in relation to the war in Syria. Throughout the course and through these empirical examples we also examine cross-cutting themes, such as: gender, trauma, emotions, silence, resilience, and others, and their role in reckoning with past wrongs. 

Theoretically informed and empirically grounded, the course adopts a multidisciplinary approach to address the question how we know and study the effects of transitional justice. It reflects critically on theorising, methods, and data in transitional justice research, and discusses implications for policy-making.

This course is delivered through a combination of lectures and seminars totalling a minimum of 25 hours across Autumn Term. This course includes a reading week in Week 6 of Autumn Term.

The course will provide or mediate additional learning opportunities, such as research seminars on topics directly linked to the theme(s) covered in the course. These will serve to reinforce learning objectives by creating an opportunity for students to engage with core issues outside regular classes.

Students will be expected to produce 1 presentation and 1 essay in the AT.

• Bakiner, Onur (2016) Truth Commissions: Memory, Power, and Legitimacy (Philadelphia: Pennsylvania University Press)
• Campbell, Kirsten (2023) The Justice of Humans: Subject, Society and Sexual Violence in International Criminal Justice (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press)
• Chinkin, Christine and Kaldor, Mary (2018) International Law and New Wars (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press)
• Cohen, Stanley (2000) States of Denial: Knowing About Atrocities and Suffering (Cambridge: Polity Press)
• Fridman, Orli (2022) Memory Activism and Digital Practices After Conflict (Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press)
• Heller, Kevin Jon (2011) The Nuremberg Military Tribunals and the Origins of International Criminal Law (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
• Hughes, James and Denisa Kostovicova (eds) (2018) Rethinking Reconciliation and Transitional Justice After Conflict (Abingdon: Routledge)
• Kostovicova, Denisa (2023) Reconciliation by Stealth: How People Talk About War Crimes (Ithaca: Cornell University Press)
• Orentlicher, Diane (2018) Some Kind of Justice: The ICTY’s Impact in Bosnia and Serbia (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press)
• Roht-Arriaza, Naomi, Mariezcurrena, Javier (eds) (2006) Transitional Justice in the Twenty-First Century: Beyond Truth versus Justice (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
• Sharp, Dustin N. (2018), Rethinking Transitional Justice for the Twenty-First Century: Beyond the End of History (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press)
• Shaw, Rosalind, Waldorf, Lars, Hazan, Pierre (eds) (2010) Localizing Transitional Justice: Interventions and Priorities after Mass Violence (Stanford: Stanford University Press).
• Teitel, Ruti (2013) Humanity’s Law (Oxford: Oxford University Press)

Essay (100%, 5000 words) in the WT.